Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) reporting has evolved from a niche concern to a central component of corporate strategy and compliance. In 2025, businesses face mounting legal obligations to disclose ESG metrics and demonstrate their commitment to sustainability, equity, and ethical governance. This shift is driven by regulators, investors, and consumers demanding greater transparency and accountability.
However, navigating the ESG landscape is no small feat. Companies must address a range of challenges, from data collection and compliance costs to managing stakeholder expectations. This article explores the growing importance of ESG reporting, the legal requirements for 2025, the most pressing challenges businesses face, and strategies to turn ESG compliance into a competitive advantage.
What is ESG Reporting and Why Does It Matter?
ESG reporting refers to the disclosure of a company’s performance in three critical areas:
- Environmental: Includes metrics like carbon emissions, energy use, water conservation, and waste management.
- Social: Covers workforce diversity, human rights, supply chain ethics, and community engagement.
- Governance: Focuses on corporate ethics, leadership transparency, shareholder rights, and anti-corruption policies.
Why it matters:
- Investor Demand: ESG compliance is a priority for institutional investors, who view it as a measure of long-term stability.
- Regulatory Compliance: Governments are implementing stricter rules to ensure companies meet sustainability and ethical standards.
- Reputational Benefits: Strong ESG performance enhances brand reputation, attracting customers and talent.
Example: In 2024, leading tech companies improved ESG ratings by adopting renewable energy and enhancing diversity transparency. This trend facilitated favorable green bond issuances, echoing deals like KPN’s €500 million bond.
New ESG Reporting Requirements for 2025
Governments and regulators are introducing new ESG mandates to ensure businesses provide accurate and actionable data. Here are the key updates:
- Mandatory Climate Disclosures:
- The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) now requires publicly traded companies to include climate-related risks, greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and energy transition plans in their annual reports.
- Disclosure of Scope 1 (direct emissions) and Scope 2 (indirect emissions from energy use) is mandatory, with larger firms encouraged to report Scope 3 (supply chain emissions) voluntarily.
Example: A global retailer (Amazon) faced backlash in 2024 for omitting Scope 3 emissions, prompting shareholder activism and regulatory scrutiny. This highlights the growing demand for comprehensive emissions reporting.
- Diversity and Inclusion Metrics:
- States like California and Illinois require publicly traded companies to report on board diversity, pay equity, and supply chain labor practices.
- Companies must demonstrate tangible progress toward equity goals, such as increasing the representation of underrepresented groups.
- Governance Accountability:
- New standards mandate the disclosure of whistleblower protections, anti-corruption measures, and executive pay ratios.
Implications: Non-compliance can lead to fines, shareholder lawsuits, and reputational damage. For instance, in 2023, an energy company was fined $10 million for misleading climate disclosures, underscoring the legal and financial risks of inadequate ESG reporting.
Top Challenges in ESG Reporting
While ESG reporting offers significant benefits, businesses face numerous obstacles in meeting these requirements. Here are the top challenges:
- Data Collection and Accuracy:
- Gathering accurate data across diverse operations and supply chains is one of the most significant hurdles.
- Example: A manufacturing firm struggled to track emissions from its global suppliers, leading to incomplete reporting and criticism from stakeholders.
- Standardization and Compliance:
- The lack of universal ESG reporting standards creates confusion. Companies must navigate varying frameworks, such as the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) and Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), alongside local regulations like the SEC climate rules and EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD).
- Example: In 2024, the EU’s Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) expanded ESG disclosure rules, requiring over 50,000 companies to align with stricter, standardized frameworks, highlighting the complexity of navigating global regulations.
- Costs of Implementation:
- Building systems for ESG data collection and reporting requires substantial investment, particularly for small and mid-sized businesses.
- Example: A retail chain allocated 10% of its annual budget to implement ESG tracking software, highlighting the financial burden for smaller organizations.
- Greenwashing Risks:
- Overstating or misrepresenting ESG achievements, known as “greenwashing,” can lead to regulatory penalties and reputational harm.
- Example: In 2022, a consumer goods company faced a $5 million fine for advertising products as “eco-friendly” without substantiating its claims.
- Stakeholder Expectations:
- Balancing the diverse and sometimes conflicting demands of investors, employees, customers, and regulators is a constant challenge. Misaligned priorities can result in public criticism or loss of trust.
- Example: In 2024, 85% of large-cap U.S. companies disclosed emissions, up from 54% in 2019. Microsoft shared Scope 3 challenges, while Walmart faces target delays.
- Supply Chain Complexity:
- Ensuring ESG compliance across global supply chains, particularly for Scope 3 emissions and labor practices, adds another layer of difficulty.
- Example: Fashion brands like Gucci and Bottega Veneta faced ongoing challenges in 2024 meeting supply chain ESG targets, struggling with transparency and ethical labor practices despite consumer demand for sustainability.
Global Trends in ESG Reporting
International regulations are driving the push for ESG standardization, influencing U.S. businesses operating abroad.
- European Union’s CSRD:
- Requires comprehensive ESG disclosures, including sustainability risks and supply chain impacts.
- Non-EU companies generating more than €150 million in annual revenue in the EU must comply.
- Global Frameworks:
- The GRI and TCFD provide voluntary standards that are increasingly seen as benchmarks for global ESG reporting.
Example: A U.S. pharmaceutical company with EU operations adopted the CSRD early, boosting its ESG rating and securing $200 million in sustainable financing, aligning with industry leaders like Merck and Teva.
Practical Steps for Businesses
To overcome these challenges and thrive in the ESG era, businesses should take proactive measures:
- Define Clear Objectives:
- Identify ESG priorities aligned with your industry, operations, and stakeholder expectations.
- Leverage Technology:
- Invest in data analytics and ESG reporting tools to streamline processes and ensure accuracy.
- Engage Stakeholders:
- Foster collaboration with employees, suppliers, and investors to align on ESG goals.
- Monitor Compliance:
- Stay informed about evolving regulations and seek expert advice to avoid legal pitfalls.
- Adopt Global Frameworks:
- Voluntary adoption of recognized standards like GRI and TCFD can enhance credibility and simplify reporting for multinational operations.
Example: In 2024, Apple aligned ESG goals with stakeholder expectations, leveraging AI-driven reporting tools and adopting TCFD standards. This proactive approach boosted transparency, stakeholder trust, and regulatory compliance, setting a benchmark for the tech industry.
The Business Case for ESG Reporting
Beyond compliance, ESG reporting offers significant advantages that can drive business success:
- Enhanced Reputation: Companies with strong ESG practices are seen as ethical and responsible, boosting customer loyalty and employee satisfaction.
- Investor Confidence: Transparent reporting increases access to sustainable financing and attracts socially conscious investors.
- Competitive Edge: Proactive ESG initiatives help businesses mitigate risks, reduce costs, and gain a market advantage.
Example: Tech startups can boost valuations by up to 20% through transparent ESG reporting, showcasing sustainability and social initiatives, reflecting trends seen in companies like Sustech and Monday.com.
The ESG revolution is transforming the corporate world, placing transparency and accountability at the forefront of business strategy. In 2025, businesses must navigate evolving regulations, overcome significant challenges, and meet the expectations of increasingly ESG-conscious stakeholders.
By embracing ESG reporting as a strategic opportunity rather than a compliance burden, companies can build trust, attract investment, and position themselves for long-term success in a rapidly changing global landscape. The journey may be complex, but the rewards are well worth the effort for those willing to lead the charge toward a sustainable future.
Subscribe to our newsletters and the “Layman Litigation” monthly magazine for more such updates.
